Dice probability without the headache: pools, modifiers, and advantage
You don't need a statistics course to run a better game. You need three ideas: one die is a straight line, several dice make a hill, and a modifier shoves the hill sideways. Everything else is garnish.
One die is a straight line
Roll a single d12 and every result from 1 to 12 is equally likely โ about 8.3% each, averaging 6.5. There's no "typical" result; a 1 is exactly as likely as a 12, every roll. That's what makes single-die systems feel swingy: heroes faceplant and land impossible shots at the same rate, because the die has no opinion. A d20 works the same way, just with 5% steps. When a game feels like a coin-flip factory, this flat line is why.
Two dice make a hill
Roll 2d6 instead and the totals run 2 to 12 โ a similar range โ but the odds pile up in the middle. There are 36 ways the two dice can land. Six of them total 7, making it the most likely result at about 17%. Only one combination makes a 2, and only one makes a 12. The full spread:
- 2 or 12: about 3% each โ the rare extremes
- 3 or 11: about 6% each
- 4 or 10: about 8% each
- 5 or 9: about 11% each
- 6 or 8: about 14% each
- 7: about 17% โ the peak of the hill
Two-thirds of all 2d6 rolls land between 5 and 9, and the average is 7 โ slightly higher than 1d12's 6.5, with far fewer disasters and far fewer miracles. Same dice bag, completely different personality: pools feel steady and competent, single dice feel chaotic. Neither is better; they're different genres wearing the same numbers.
What a +2 really does
A modifier doesn't change the shape of your odds โ it slides the whole thing sideways. On a flat die that's simple: each +1 on a d20 is worth exactly 5 percentage points of success chance, so +2 turns a 50% shot (needing 11 or more) into a 60% shot (needing 9 or more). On a hill, the same +2 is worth more or less depending on where your target sits. Needing 8 or more on 2d6 succeeds about 42% of the time; with +2 you only need the dice to show 6, and success jumps to about 72%. That +2 was worth thirty points, because it moved you across the crowded middle of the hill. When the target is out at the edges, the same modifier buys much less โ there's hardly any probability mass out there to pick up. Rule of thumb: bonuses feel biggest when the roll was a genuine toss-up to begin with.
Advantage and disadvantage, in plain English
Advantage means roll two d20s and keep the higher; disadvantage, keep the lower. Three numbers tell the story. Your chance of a natural 20 nearly doubles, from 5% to about 9.75% โ it's one minus the chance both dice miss it. Your chance of a natural 1 collapses to 0.25%. And your average roll climbs from 10.5 to about 13.8. But advantage is not a flat +3 bonus, however often it's described that way. It helps most in the middle: needing an 11, a straight roll succeeds 50% of the time, while advantage succeeds 75% โ that's behaving like +5. Near the edges it shrinks: needing a natural 20, you only gain those extra few points up to 9.75%. Disadvantage is the mirror image โ average about 7.2, crits nearly vanish, and fumbles bloom to 9.75%. In short: advantage is a strong, reliable nudge toward competence that quietly refuses to make anyone invincible.
Picking dice for the feel you want
Now you can choose on purpose. Want heroic chaos, where the new player might slay the dragon and the veteran might trip over a rug? Flat single dice. Want a crew that usually performs like professionals, with failure as the exception? Dice pools and their hill. Want steady growth you can feel? Modifiers, which slide the odds a fixed, knowable amount. Most arguments about "broken" builds and "unfair" encounters are really arguments about these three shapes wearing costumes.
See it for yourself
The fastest way to learn this is to roll a few hundred dice and watch the hill form. The Dice Atelier rolls proper 3D pools on twenty themed tables if you want the full game-night treatment, and the classic dice roller is there when you just need numbers fast. Either way: may your sevens be frequent and your ones be somebody else's.